Tegan and Sara played the Aragon Friday night. I listen to them all the time. I saw them perform at the Hollywood Bowl this summer and was a bit underwhelmed. I assumed it was because the venue was so enormous and the sound system didn’t pack much of a punch, but I had a similar experience at the Aragon.
One reason for not having my potential for enjoyment maximized may have been the song choices. They began with “The Ocean,” which was really dull, then played “On Directing,” which picked things up a bit, but then played “The Cure,” which dragged again. All of those songs are on their newest album, “Sainthood,” which I’m not the biggest fan of. Most of the songs that I do like on that album are Sara songs (ie. “On Directing”). Tegan’s are pretty weak (ie. “The Ocean” and “The Cure”). If they were to play the best “Sainthood” songs, Tegan wouldn’t be singing very many of hers. Perhaps they try to balance the number of songs. Normally I wouldn’t oppose, but “Sainthood” is so Sara-heavy that the balance worked to their disadvantage. They may have also considered it cliché to open with the first track of their newest album, but “Arrow” would have been a much better opener that “The Ocean.”
I think I also realized that I’m not a big fan of their style live. Both girls are charming and fine musicians (along with the band), but don’t possess much stage presence. I wanted to see some swagger. They also change guitars between every song. I don’t know much about alternate tunings, but it would behoove them to consider grouping similar tunings when planning the set. They lost so much momentum between songs.
I love listening to Tegan and Sara records, but they just don’t put on a very dynamic performance. I’m sure some people really loved the show, but me? Well, I like everything big. I didn’t dislike the show, I was just a bit unsatisfied.