I must say that my first trip to the Hollywood Bowl was a very good one. It was a perfect night to be outside, the scenery was very pretty, and the venue's size did not hinder my enjoyment as much as I expected. My one qualm was with the sound. Though clear, the sound of more "rocking" songs seemed a bit wimpy. But I suppose this is understandable as the venue was intended for orchestral music, not rock and roll.
The New Pornographers took the stage first and played a very tight 30-minute set. Their performance of "Challengers" (the most acoustic song of their set) was very good and displayed gorgeous harmonies, but the chatter of the crowd took a lot away from the moment. It's too bad because that was the one song not hindered by the sound of the Bowl. There are a few songs I wish they would have played, but in 30 minutes they couldn't please everyone. I am pleased with what I got: a well-performed high-energy set of great music. The only issue I took was that singer A.C. Newman seemed to struggle with the harmonies of the last two songs "Sing Me Spanish Techno" and "The Bleeding Hearts Show." I doubt that this was an isolated incident because I couldn't imagine his voice hitting some of the notes on any occasion.
Tegan and Sara were up and running within 15 minutes of the end of the Pornographers set. Their first song, "Dark Come Soon," grabbed the audience's attention right away, but they were unable to keep that very firm grip. They used a good balance of banter and music to keep the audience engaged within their allotted 45 minutes, but suffered from what appeared to be a lack of practice. They played a gig in Seattle two days earlier, but are not currently touring and probably have not had tremendous amounts of rehearsal time with the band. Some of the transitions were a little sloppy and left the songs feeling less than dynamic. "Living Room" was the only song from their first two albums in their "Con"-heavy set and I was left wishing for a bit more diversity. I really enjoyed finally seeing Tegan and Sara live for the first time, but felt like seeing them headline a smaller venue would be much more fitting. "Nineteen" and "The Con" would probably rock more with a louder sound system and people would not be chatting during their quiet numbers. So this was basically a tease for me.
Then Death Cab for Cutie took the stage. I feel like I should begin to describe their set at the end of it: 17,000+ people on their feet, applauding as though they had just seen one of the most riveting performances in recent music history. Because they had... for about 8 minutes. Death Cab opened without the Philharmonic with a rocking "Marching Bands of Manhattan" and made cool transition from a song I'm not familiar with into "The New Year," but that was about all I liked about the first half of the set. The privilege of watching Chris Walla shred wasn't even enough to keep me interested. I admit I'm kind of growing tired of Death Cab, I don't like their new music at all, and I was bitter that such a mediocre band would sell out such a huge venue. So this review is a bit biased. I got my wish and they played "Summer Skin," but they didn't do it with the Philharmonic which continues to puzzle me.
After about 40 minutes, they left the stage promising to return with the Philharmonic. I have to admit that adding all those instruments made their sound much more dynamic. I don't really understand their insistence on rocking with songs like "Movie Script Ending" when more melodic songs (like "Summer Skin") really could have benefitted from the orchestra. After about 30 minutes of slightly improved music the audience was brought to the previously mentioned 8 minutes of euphoria. Yes, I am talking about the "Transatlanticism" finale with the LA Philharmonic in tow that I new was coming. I expected it, but I never could have been ready for it. The performance was great and the Philharmoic added beautiful texture. I was afraid they would make the song too busy, but they were able to evoke the wide-open ocean sound that they do so well on the record. And just when I thought it couldn't get better, the fireworks began. It was such a perfect visual and audial crescendo. Really perfect. I can't think of a performance that made me feel like that. It's amazing how a good finale can make you forgive an hour of mediocrity.