For a time I had decided to boycott violent films. My media studies, observations of children (especially boys) fantasizing about violence, and the presence of violence in the world led me to categorize violent entertainment as inappropriate content. No exceptions. For a while, that boycott kept me from watching my beloved X-Men in their new film, X-Men: First Class, but I recently gave in, watched the film, and was thoroughly enchanted.
I credit the film’s success to its focus on Charles Xavier. What fascinates me about Xavier is his commitment to peace and that he risks his own life to defend those who hate him. His virtue is almost Christ-like and his reluctance to fight is heavily rooted in Just War Theory: a theory that is at the core of my personal view of violence in the world and media. Xavier’s pacifistic philosophy was enough to redeem the X-Men in my eyes, but I still find flaws in the X-Men’s distribution.
Not all of the X-Men share Xavier’s nonviolent philosophy and that is the primary conflict of the series. The battle of wills in X-Men is complex and requires a mature, contemplative audience. However, the X-Men and other superheroes are often marketed to children in the forms of cartoons and action figures. Children will catch the explosions and the punches, but miss the debate on violence’s merit. We need to take a step back and consider the risk we are taking by packaging such mature content for immature minds.
No comments:
Post a Comment